Hijab has always been painted as a fairly black and white issue. The arguments are usually drawn along these lines; Either you’re religious and you wear hijab or you’re not religious and you don’t wear hijab, either you believe hijab is obligatory or you don’t, either you’re a ‘traditional’ Muslim or a ‘liberal’ one. Over the years I remember two times a shuyukh explicitly said they would not associate with a student who took off their hijab. Over the years, I’ve witnessed, that anyone who took off the hijab was concluded to have left Islam —which often became a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Conversations on hijab have been mostly silenced, that does not mean that there aren’t dissenters but that those who dissent are automatically seen as irreligious and unworthy of being legitimized within the mainstream Muslim discourse. Even women who fear/ed for their lives after 9/11 and in Trump’s America were/are told essentially to keep the faith and don the scarf or stay home. Early in my studies, a shaykh told me that if one believes wearing hijab is not obligatory they have committed an act of kufr (disbelief) since the injunction to wear hijab is in the Quran.
What is specifically discussed in Quran is for women to cover their bosoms with their Khimar, “…and not display their beauty except what is apparent, and they should place their khumur over their bosoms…” And in the verse concerning drawing the Khimar to cover the bosom (some) scholars say that the Khimar itself was a particular kind of scarf worn by women over their head and thus God is instructing women to take the scarf over their head and also place it over their bosom, as Shaykh Abdullah Adhami explains here:
Khimar literally means a head cover (that) drapes over the head, keeping the face exposed and comes to slightly above the center point… so that’s why it (the Quran) doesn’t say to cover your heads because Khimar means a head covering… to make sure that the tails of the Khimar cover the chest because in Jahilliyah (before Islam) the tails of the Khimar use to go backward… would deliberately expose the chest by leaving off the Khimar backward and Allah says that Khimar you wear… every culture had head coverings… to cover the chest as well.
But El Fadl states that this idea is perhaps not as sound or not as agreed upon as many assume:
Many scholars have argued that khimār by definition is a piece of cloth that covers a woman’s entire body and is drawn upon the face, so in effect, enclosing a woman’s entire body in a veil. Many others have argued that a khimār is a piece of cloth that covers the hair and the entire body except for the face. However, in my view, and God knows best, both schools of thought—that which contends that the khimār covers the face, and that which contends that the khimār covers the hair but not the face—are ahistorical in presuming the existence of a historical practice that has not been proven. The evidence that the khimār in pre-Islamic Hijaz covered the face or covered the hair is simply not there. The only thing that the verse allows us to say conclusively is that Muslim women were called upon to draw a piece of cloth (khimār) over the juyūb (bosoms)—whether it covered the hair or the face, we don’t know. In other words, the Qurʾan in this verse calls upon women to cover their bosoms. Anything beyond that would require extensive research into the social practices of khimār dressing at the time of revelation, and the historical evidence is far more diverse and complex than many contemporary scholars assume it to be.
(Some) scholars of the past also have made a distinction between the dress of a freedwoman vs. the dress of a slave woman. One might ask, what does one’s societal position have to do with a religious edict?
Some classical scholars claimed that the purpose of the revelation was to distinguish between free women and slave girls by instructing free women to cover with their jilbāb because slave girls did not wear a jilbāb. Other sources report that the purpose was precisely the opposite: Muslim women would cover with the jilbāb so that scoundrels could not tell the difference between a slave and a free woman, and so they would be unable to harass either. It is clear by the very language of the verse the purpose of this injunction is to protect women from harm, and in my view, it is also clear that the narrative sought to support equity between classes and the equal treatment of women of divergent social status.
El Fadl also states:
For classical jurists, the issue was the social status of women. Free women were expected to cover their bodies; slave girls/women were not expected to cover their bodies except for the area between the knee and the navel.
El Fadl concludes:
…that the critical issue for the classical jurists was not fitnah or sexual seduction, but rather the social status that various forms of dress would signify. If by definition the arms and hair of women were considered ʿawrah, then it would make no difference whether a woman was of slave or free status. The fact that the vast majority of classical jurists set different expectations depending on the social position of women underscores the fact that customary law and social habits played a critical role in this field.
El Fadl further states:
It is clear by the very language of the verse the purpose of this injunction is to protect women from harm, and in my view, it is also clear that the narrative sought to support equity between classes and the equal treatment of women of divergent social status.
One of the main reasons Muslim women take issue with hijab is because of the harassment and discrimination they face as visible Muslims. This being coupled with the fact that protection by Muslim men against said harassment and discrimination is often non-existent. It’s true that not everywhere in America is the same, nor is everyone’s experience the same, some of us have never been harassed or discriminated against because of hijab (or at least have never felt this was the case) others have died at the hands of Islamophobia and most have experienced some form of unease post 9/11.
On the point of livelihood, El Fadl states:
Very often when it came to working women, such as women in the bazaar, jurists would allow the women not to cover their hair or would contend that women who had to make a living should dress in a fashion that would not encumber their livelihood.
El Fadl argues that our contemporary views on hijab are more strict than they have been in the past and even more strict that Jewish and Christian religious law:
I want to point out that it is rather ironic that in the modern age the hijab has become symbolic of Islamic identity… It is rather ironic that modern Muslims, at least since the late 1970s, have chosen to make the head-covering an integral component of identity politics when their own scriptural injunctions are far less dispositive than their Jewish and Christian counterparts. There is nothing uniquely Islamic about the hijab except for the fact that Muslim social movements, at least since the late 1970s, have chosen to make it a part of Islamic catechism.
Hijab is a beautiful ayah (sigh) of devotion to God but it’s sadly become a politicized litmus test for religiosity. Must those who question the importance or even legitimacy of the hijab be automatically assumed to be irreligious? And must all questions concerning hijab be assumed illegitimate?
In the end, El Fadl concludes that modesty and not hijab (the headscarf) must be the emphasis:
In my view, humility, modesty, and personal piety are far more worthy in Allah’s eyes than any formal physical attire regardless of its sanctified appearance. And God knows best.
_____
Read his full argument here.
Note: The republishing of excerpts from El Fadl’s Fatwa on Hijab is not an endorsement of his view, I am not knowledgeable enough on this issue to agree or disagree with his argument the point of this post was rather to reflect on the discourse around this issue.





Salaam, so my points on this article of yours may seem scattered about, but that is just how my mind works as of now. That being said,
“One of the main reasons Muslim women take issue with hijab is because of the harassment and discrimination they face as visible Muslims. This being coupled with the fact that protection by Muslim men against said harassment and discrimination is often non-existent. It’s true that not everywhere in America is the same, nor is everyone’s experience the same, some of us have never been harassed or discriminated against because of hijab (or at least have never felt this was the case) others have died at the hands of Islamophobia and most have experienced some form of unease post 9/11.”
As highlighted by this scholar here (https://ia801308.us.archive.org/23/items/PurdahTheStatusOfWomenInIslamBySayyidAbulAalaMaududi/Purdah%20The%20Status%20Of%20Women%20In%20Islam%20By%20Sayyid%20Abul%20Aala%20Maududi.pdf)
Objections to the hijab began before 9/11 and before Muslims began mass immigrating to western countries (Ala Maududi’s observations were based around the 1960s to 1970s on the criticisms of hijab in Pakistan/India). And although he is writing on Purdah, and not hijab, he also incorporates that into his book. And if we look at the arguments made against hijab back then and after 9/11 and or immigration to the west, then we see that the arguments are curiously similar if not the same in many regards. Which makes me think that the core reason and what galvanized many muslim women to take issue with hijab is not entirely because the west made it difficult (although that does contribute), but more so because of their own corrupt nafs. That is, though they will never admit it and want to walk around thinking they are modest, fact is they on many levels want to broadcast their beauty to the public, specifically to men and sometimes women as well and gain that social gratification. I would argue it is instinctual in women, that is to advertise their beauty and reap the attention they get. This is evidenced by the fact that when muslim women do take off the hijab, it doesn’t just stop there. They also stye their hair, dye it various shades, and generally manipulate their hair to make it look attractive. And I am talking like immediately after discarding the hijab they start doing all of this, so it isn’t a delayed reaction. So if it was merely due to safety that many take it off, then why progress to all of that almost immediately? Of course the answer is obvious, for the overwhelming majority of non-hijabi sisters, blaming it entirely on the west’s aggressive approach towards hijab is the scapegoat from realizing that ever since a young age, they would oftentimes see non-muslim women doll their hair up, and naturally wanted to do the same. So they oftentimes use the west’s aggressive approach towards hijab as a convenient excuse to dissolve any personal blame for their decision to not wear hijab, and live out what they always wanted to do but couldn’t because of familial/religious obligations. I am not saying that there aren’t some sisters who genuinely struggle with hijab and fear for their lives due to the aggressive western approach towards hijab, but like I said, to make that jump from hijab to not being a hijabi and dolling up your hair requires more than just simple fear of western attitudes towards hijab, and all too conveniently dissolves any and all personal blame for one’s own sinful actions.
“Over the years, I’ve witnessed, that anyone who took off the hijab was concluded to have left Islam —which often became a self-fulfilling prophecy.”
I understand that perhaps you have more thoughts about this statement of yours. But I often times see this statement used to essentially completely blame the apostasy of a non-hijabi sister on the “public” or “scholars”, etc. And while the former may have had something to do with it, as I said before, it isn’t like these sisters have pure intentions and may be letting less on than they want others to know. Suffice to say, I feel that I don’t need to tell you this, as multiple times in your articles you have pointed out the issue with women victimizing and pushing 100% of the blame of their wrong actions on others in order to feel better about themselves, rather than acknowledging their own blame may have had a heavier hand in her fate.
“Early in my studies, a shaykh told me that if one believes wearing hijab is not obligatory they have committed an act of kufr (disbelief) since the injunction to wear hijab is in the Quran……
that the critical issue for the classical jurists was not fitnah or sexual seduction, but rather the social status that various forms of dress would signify. If by definition the arms and hair of women were considered ʿawrah, then it would make no difference whether a woman was of slave or free status. The fact that the vast majority of classical jurists set different expectations depending on the social position of women underscores the fact that customary law and social habits played a critical role in this field…
I want to point out that it is rather ironic that in the modern age the hijab has become symbolic of Islamic identity… It is rather ironic that modern Muslims, at least since the late 1970s, have chosen to make the head-covering an integral component of identity politics when their own scriptural injunctions are far less dispositive than their Jewish and Christian counterparts. There is nothing uniquely Islamic about the hijab except for the fact that Muslim social movements, at least since the late 1970s, have chosen to make it a part of Islamic catechism.
Hijab is a beautiful ayah (sigh) of devotion to God but it’s sadly become a politicized litmus test for religiosity. Must those who question the importance or even legitimacy of the hijab be automatically assumed to be irreligious? And must all questions concerning hijab be assumed illegitimate?”
I also remember a sheikh (Dr. Jonathan Brown) who made the curious point that conservatism, and that of hijab, didn’t spontaneously spring up out of nowhere. But it was a reaction, a reaction to the western cultural program to sexualize the muslim world. Which also seeks to explain why Christians and Jews aren’t conservative anymore but Muslims are increasingly so. In general he made the point that conservatism springs up that where liberalism/sexualization springs up. Not that conservatism is bad, but the kind you are talking about is what he meant. As both are polar opposites of each other, and human beings are far more likely to gravitate towards extremities than they are to take the less common middle path. In fact, I remember my grandfather who mentioned that during this time (1960s to now) In a muslim majority city in India where he lived he would notice that “You would see women walking out of their homes dressed in a manner unthinkable in the past, and then you saw a sheikh speaking in a harsh tone about hijab and restricting hijab, the girl would say that “you are not modern enough and are backwards” and the sheikh would say “you are sinful and stuck in your ways, you are out of the fold of Islam” and so it would repeat in a cycle like this”.
You mentioned hijab being a political litmus, I think it similar to how in the east, western clothing is often times the litmus between “modernity” and “backwardness”. Wear a traditional clothing and you are seen as “backward”, but wear a sleek suit and all of a sudden you belong to this exclusive club of “modernity” and “progressiveness”. While I don’t think either are justifiable, clearly both exist as reactions to each other, and will continue to exist as long as both are present.
Ironically Fadl talks of social and cultural habits/nuances, I also remember a sheikh using this same logic to argue why hijab nowadays should be more stricter and all the more necessary (even niqab) than in the past. Firstly, they say that the reason why fitnah/sexual seduction wasn’t their main worry back then was, well they lived in a sensitized society (mostly) where sexuality was hardly a public subject and, by modern standards, people were so shy about things concerning sexuality that they could be described as “prudes”, where women weren’t in droves self-sexualizing themselves, so overall they could “afford” to say loosen aspects of hijab back then and let social habits come into play. And I don’t need to lecture you on just how things are in this day and age and why, unlike back then, it is necessary for the critical issue of hijab being that of a safeguard against sexualization/fitnah for the ummah. Heck, I would argue that if there ever was a social context where restrictive/harsh notions of hijab were needed would be nowadays as opposed to the past. This also includes niqab, burqa, etc. being more necessary than it ever was in the past (not that it wasn’t necessary back then, but you get what I mean). So essentially nowadays, we cannot “afford” to loosen hijab up even according to permissible standards past fuqaha allowed because of the world we live in (we could discuss why the world is so sexualized now, but that is a topic for a different day) like how strictness of hijab, niqab, burqa, etc. pays off immensely nowadays while it seemed unnecessary in the past.
MashaAllah, thank you for taking the time to write this comment. I greatly appreciate your perspective and agree with a lot of the points you made. One thing I was going to touch on in the article that you mentioned is why many women who take off their hijab than go to the other ‘extreme’ of not only showing their hair but forgetting all modesty standards completely. Of course, I don’t know why and it could be like you said, that some women are not solely taking off their hijab for reasons of fear but simply because they want to beautify and receive male attention. I also wonder if it could be another self/communal-fulfilling prophecy, that is, maybe because there is so much emphasis on hijab once it’s off people forget about modesty altogether (of course I need to think this theory through). I have a friend who took off her hijab and maintained a certain degree of modesty I also know of women who have never worn hijab but still retain modesty some even donning shoulder scarves so I don’t think it’s impossible to maintain modesty without hijab, whether it’s likely is a different question.
Your point about hijab paying off even more in our times is something I think is a consideration for anyone contemplating taking off or putting on the scarf, while wearing hijab may attract Islamophobic attention it also (often) detracts male attention ad so either path has it’s own ‘hardship’.