Comments on: Economic and emotional pressures in women’s ‘choice’ to work http://bythefigandtheolive.com/womenworking/ Increased Stations Thu, 05 Mar 2020 23:17:55 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.3.3 By: Noor http://bythefigandtheolive.com/womenworking/#comment-413 Thu, 05 Mar 2020 23:17:55 +0000 http://bythefigandtheolive.com/?p=4813#comment-413 Thanks for your valuable commentary, feeamaillah.

]]>
By: Noor http://bythefigandtheolive.com/womenworking/#comment-412 Fri, 28 Feb 2020 02:51:35 +0000 http://bythefigandtheolive.com/?p=4813#comment-412 Thank you, Alhumdulilah appreciate the kind words 🙂

]]>
By: aisha http://bythefigandtheolive.com/womenworking/#comment-410 Tue, 25 Feb 2020 12:46:38 +0000 http://bythefigandtheolive.com/?p=4813#comment-410 I meant to say that men don’t value women who stay home, as much as they like on to doing the housework. My point being they takie it for granted.

]]>
By: aisha http://bythefigandtheolive.com/womenworking/#comment-409 Tue, 25 Feb 2020 12:42:15 +0000 http://bythefigandtheolive.com/?p=4813#comment-409 Salaam Alaikum Sister Nurriden,
This was a great article! I especially liked how you mentioned that many women feel compelled because their husbands think any kind of contribution to the household and actually resent having to shoulder the financial responsibilities by themselves. There are other points related to economic/ emotional force that I wish you had mentioned including:

1. Economic force doesn’t just come from families not having enougeh money to support themselves. It also comes from governments that depend on women being part of the workforce. People talk about the need for this country to provide free health care all the time. But in parts of the health care sector like nursing or obstetrics, the majority of workers are women. The same is true teaching, home health aids for the elderly, etc. Who Is supposed to hose sorts of jobs for the nation if women stay home? Modern society requires more and more people to participate at a humbler level.
2. couples have fewer children, and then children typically to school eventually. There is no question that childrearing ctake up a lot of one’s time but it doesn’t take all of one’s time all the time.
3. Society, including men, value women’s work at home. This is shown in the behavior of men towards their wives in my parents, and grandparents generations. The Sunnah shows us many examples of how it’s an ideal ofr a husband to consult on family, and even political matter before making decisions. But this is not a requirement, and so many men don’t consult their stay at home wives on anything. A woman who earns money, and contributes it to the household budget cannot ignored in exactly the same way.
3. A lot of women tend to draw a sense of confidence from working because they are interacting with the rest of society, and feel a sense of accomplishment in earning money.
4. Relationship stability: If a housewife ends up divorced from her husband, what is she supposed to do? Even if you are not divorced, you are the child of divorce, know someone whose parents are divorced, etc. It is so pervasive that it makes women afraid to depend on potential husbands, and by extension the husband’s family for support.
5. Connected to this: the stigma of divorce is connected to women staying at home. When divorce happens to a woman who is housewife in Pakistan and in desi culture more broadly, she has to return to her own family’s house whether it’s her father or brothers. If the woman working, she can at least compensate her family for taking her back. But if she was a housewife, the family will view her as a financial burden, an extra mouth to feed.They arranged the marriage, and they expected to stay married to the guy come hell or high water. Tis aspect of the problem of divorce is less visible in the American context b/c in the United States, a divorced woman, even an without education, can go on welfare, get a minimum wage job, and rent an apartment to live in under how name without she is a bad, dishonorable person. But in Pakistan, this is impossible. Sure we don’t live in Pakistan but I think that’s where the stigma comes from.
6. Inheritance in Islam: In the past, many wealthy women could accept staying at home becuaase they received inheritances from their families that they could fall back on. This inherantce could be in the form of land or a business that could be invested so that the income is regular. Of course, only wealthy women actually benefited from this. Poorer families tended to ignore Islamic inheritance laws which partly why this is a problem today. I would laso point that a lot of the time, if we inheritance it’s not always enough to live on and can’t be used as a backup when the male breadwinner family that we wanted doesn’t always work out in the way we hope it will.
Ultimately life is not easy. And we have to trust in the arrangments that were ordained for us by Allah (SWT). There is no perfect solution.I hope I was not being overly critical, and do think your case for women being forced to work was a good summation of most of the problems that we have.

]]>
By: Fouad Ibrahim http://bythefigandtheolive.com/womenworking/#comment-408 Mon, 24 Feb 2020 23:27:59 +0000 http://bythefigandtheolive.com/?p=4813#comment-408 You write so well. Thanks for speaking uncomfortable truths. Keep it up.

]]>