As for sisters getting married when feelings result. The solution I advocate for at least amongst us shias is to then utilize mutah (temporary marriage) to prevent sin. However, this clearly isn’t an option for you sunni lot so the closest thing I would say is for the girl to get married before she heads off to university.
Otherwise, there is no other magical solution out there than marriage to prevent sexual sins. Therefore, at a young age we should be teaching youth about marriage, sex, etc. The issue is nowadays Muslim parents barely teach their kids anything at all related to marriage and sex. Both the immigrant generation of parents and their offspring. So obviously we are now having a generation full of kids who are illiterate when it comes to matters of relationships. We then see this and think it is impossible to get these kids married at younger ages. When in reality, it is because of the laziness of Muslim parents to imbue expectations about relationships in their kids.
And let me clarify, we are seeing the OPPOSITE trend in neoliberal muslim circles, in terms of expectations of the opposite gender. Both sexual and Islamic. An example of this is the number of sisters who drone on and on about “true qawwams”. And you mentioned that sisters tend to find marriage off putting because of high expectations in conservative circles, men especially among the youth feel the same way nowadays in liberal circles, since we apparently aren’t “true qawwams”. To give a perspective, my demographic places me in the liberal circle and I have essentially filtered out 90% of sisters as potential marital partners who are around my age (I am a young adolescent) because they won’t quit yapping about “true qawwams”, and I have heard from brothers that marrying these “true qawwam” sisters is like hell because of their expectations, and they abuse Islam to justify this.
And since Muslims nowadays could care less about challenging liberal notions infecting muslim circles, eventually we will see this dynamic of neoliberal muslim circles be more prominent. Now, you might then interject and say that neither paradigm is right. Not the neoliberal one or the conservative one. And you would be right, both are just extremes of the other. From what I can tell, you seem to be chiefly concerned about marital practices and expectations in conservative circles, my advice is the same I would give to liberal circles as well. That is, us Muslims must challenge both liberal and conservative circles by holding BOTH brothers and sisters accountable to higher standards. Not just one at the expense of the other.
What do you mean me? I am just some random guy on the internet. I may have my ideas, but I like to base my ideas off of the sunnah. Before the whole drama went down, NAK had a very good video about the courting practices of men and women at the time of the prophet (PBUH). Essentially, it was pretty simple in the sense that a guy sees a girl he likes, he then asks the girl for the name of her wali. He then firsts goes to the wali and asks for the daughter’s hand in marriage. It takes a heavy degree of convincing, but it usually was done due to persistence. Then the guy and girl started courting each other, and the rest is history. Thing is, while all of this isn’t easy. It is doable and with practice becomes easier. Difference is Muslim youth nowadays are so lazy that they don’t even approach step 1 of this process and adopt relationship tactics from non-muslims so they can gain favor in the eyes of them.
like I said, while Muslim parents should change and make marriage easier. But to be honest, Muslim parents today are not as unreasonable as Muslim parents were during the time of The Prophet (PBUH). Some might even say the latter was even more unreasonable. But like I said, if ordinary men and women during the time of the prophet could do it, then so can the youth generation. DIfference is, the former actually had a backbone and were persistent in their cause for halal relationships. While the latter has grown to be spineless and lazy and just want the fruits of a relationship without going through the effort to do so via halal means.
]]>But in case you were still in denial about the types of sisters out there, read this https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=10155905663610350&id=576750349
As for the asexual, virgin pure, thing. Again, not sure if you are Muslim but being modest and chaste does NOT mean being asexual or a virgin. But it does mean that you DON’T have immodest interactions with non-mahram. Where did I say that sisters shouldn’t get married, they should as soon as “those feelings” start to emerge. The problem is sisters don’t pursue marriage in a HALAL and MODEST manner. We are Muslims, we appease our desires in a halal way. Anything other than the halal way is Haram or at the very least makruh. There isn’t a “spectrum” when it comes to this.
Do you want to know how pious women during the time of the prophet (PBUH) satisfied their “physical and biological needs?” Sure as heck not in the same way that a *larger amount than we want to admit* of sisters nowadays are doing so.
]]>I would disagree with the fact that the dress that muslim men wear can or cannot deter female attention. What deters attention from woman by Muslim men is when we control the type of interactions we have with women. Not neccessarily our clothing, though it may have a slight impact. This is because women don’t recieve the same biological response that men receive when they see a member of the opposite sex dressed immodestly.
Therefore, I would like to see you make an article on advice for how men achieve what I call as behavioral modesty. Or, learning to not flirt with sisters or entertain flirts from sisters. The latter may seem odd to you, but for many brothers while we are aware of the antics that non-muslim women use, many of us are still tripped up by the number of *hijabi* sisters who seem to use the same charms and tricks non-muslim women use in order to “explore our chemistry privately” with. This is evidenced by the fact that I attend a liberal western university and there seems to be such a high number of these flirtatious sisters that they might as well be a dime a dozen and they have all “hooked” many a muslim men. And when I speak to these brothers they tell me “I know it is haram, but at least this will lead to a *halal* marriage with said sister”. Only for an even bigger haram to be committed shortly after.
]]>Hope it helps!
BitTawfiq
]]>