Comments on: Polygamy, providers, and gendered roles in Islam https://bythefigandtheolive.com/polygamygenderedroles/ Increased Stations Mon, 03 Jul 2023 18:39:59 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.5.2 By: aisha https://bythefigandtheolive.com/polygamygenderedroles/#comment-504 Thu, 15 Jun 2023 21:30:18 +0000 http://bythefigandtheolive.com/?p=5574#comment-504 Also, I thought that polygany was an allowance not a right. Yes, polygany is allowed in Islam, women have no right to object if it’s what their husband wants. But in Prophet Mahammad (sws)’s own time, women in Medina were independent, and their marriages were monagamous. Ghese characteristics were understood to be customary practices. As I understand it, the Prophet did not insist on changing thier practices. He didn’t even marry any madini women himself, b/c he understood that polygany would be difficult for Madini women and their families to accept. It’s not a righteous act ofr a man to take a wife secretly or over the objections of a woman raised in a monagamous family or socity even if it’s technically legal. By contrast, a man is supposed to provide for his wife/ wives even when they have their own incomes. The only way to lessen or forgo the burden of financial provision is for him (and possibly his family), and her )and her family) to sit down together and negotiate a contract in which everyone is perfectly honest and clear about what they can/wil and can’t/won’t do. That’s what the purpose of a nikkah contract is supposed to be. Granted that the culture surrounding nikkah contracts in some cultures makes this really hard. Having said that, having one half, having one third, ore one fourth a provider is financially speaking, not the same as monagamous. If a man marries more wives, he is increasing the number of dependents that he has, and thus decreasing the amount of tiem/ money for all of them. In a context like the Unted states, where polygany illiegal and financial difficult, wouldn’t their be an expectation of wives working or contributing financially in some way so that provicer/ housewife doesn’t actually fit the polygamous family of today.

]]>
By: aisha https://bythefigandtheolive.com/polygamygenderedroles/#comment-503 Thu, 15 Jun 2023 21:06:31 +0000 http://bythefigandtheolive.com/?p=5574#comment-503 Part of the proble that we have is the emphasisis on legalism in our marriage discourse. There is no question that the education about rights and responsibilities in Islam is well intentioned, and meant to educate us and make us feel of being Muslim. I think an untinetnioned side effect seems to be that there is an increased sense of entitlement. Ths sense of entitlement was always a problem for men in South Asian culture, and probably Arab culture too. We’ve reached a stage where women are saying that theyy’ve had it, and will no longer put up with what they saw their mothers, aunts or grandmothers put up with.So the sense of entitlement from our(mostly informal) education about our rights is a new thing, a way to hit back against the self entitlement of our brothers. Naturally, this is new to our brothers who were used to relationship where women served and obeyed the men in our lives without question. The new polygany whereby brothers hit back by guilting sisters into accpeting polgany might be a form of backlash. Nautrally, sisters don’t like it. An arrognat entitled brother is bad in marriage no matter how many wives he has or joes about having. Incidentally, is joking about marriage allowed in the Sunnah? By joking about marriage, I mean specifically brothers joking about polygany, and bragging about planning to marry four wives.Aisha

]]>